I Found It – The Ultimate Heretic Detector System!

I woke up this morning intent on spending a peaceful day at our cabin with my dog.  I was looking forward to having the time to reflect on all that has happened this past month and there is a lot to reflect upon.  Unfortunately, I made the decision to post my comments for Rachel Held Evans “Rally to Restore Christian Unity” late Saturday night.  It was obvious that a couple of the folks who commented on my post were looking for the “Keep Fear Alive!” rally.  They opposed my opposition to calling people heretics who disagree with one’s theology.  One gentleman asked the questions, “ Does this mean there is no such thing as a heretic? Is so, how would we know? Or how would we warn others about them?”

As I was making the hour long drive out to my cabin this morning, I was composing a response to the heretic seekers question. It was titled, “The Second Coming of the Pharisee’s”, and I admit it did nothing to promote Christian Unity.  I was so lost in my debate with my invisible nemesis that I completely missed my turn.  I make this trip at least once a month and can navigate it with my eyes closed but I was so distracted by the temptation to debate this person I have never met, that I got completely off course.  I started to feel like something was wrong about five miles into going the wrong way, but it took almost 20 minutes before I was fully aware of just how far off course I was.

As I was doubling back, the Holy Spirit used my misdirection to remind me of something.  I don’t have to prove my faith in Christ to anyone.  I simply have to follow the one who called me and stay on course.  God has called me to a much higher purpose than debating theology with a total stranger.  While I love writing and enjoy the debates, they can become a distraction and can get us all totally off course.  Apostle Paul’s words to Timothy came to mind, “Keep reminding God’s people of these things. Warn them before God against quarreling about words; it is of no value, and only ruins those who listen.”

When I finally arrived at my cabin, I was struck by all the new growth since my last visit.  The trees are in full bloom, the butterflies have emerged, even the mushrooms and fungus have taken on brilliant colors.  For some reason this place always helps to ground me and to remind me of just how small I am.  I don’t know whose theology is right and whose is wrong.  All I know is that God called me to love people and to encourage others to love one another.

As I looked at all this new life, I thought of the new life I am seeing in our community.  I thought of the Facebook post from Joe who wrote to me yesterday, “You always believed in me and now I can believe in myself.”  I thought of Debra who shared on Thursday that for two years she sat on her porch and no one talked to her until we came into the community and now she makes a point of talking to her neighbors.  I thought of the young man who thanked Janie on Tuesday for making him help out at the food pantry.  New life comes in many forms, shapes and sizes.  However, it all comes from the same creator’s hand, birthed out of love and it produces in kind.

To my friend who asked how to detect a heretic, I would suggest you look for signs of new life birthed out of love that are producing loving relationships.  If someone’s ministry is producing people who are experiencing new life and who are learning to love like Jesus, then in my book that is more important than their doctrinal beliefs.  Those with sound doctrinal beliefs who bear no fruit are like the fig tree that Jesus cursed.

There is a ministry in our city that literally goes up to people on the street and asks them if they were to die tonight do they know where they will spend eternity.  I personally find this fear-based approach distasteful.  However, I cannot deny that this particular ministry is producing people who love God and who are seeking to love their neighbors.  I will never agree with their theology but I respect that God has called them to their particular way of doing ministry and I pray for their success.

I don’t think using one’s interpretation of scripture as the basis of determining their heretic status makes any sense.  There is no one way of interpreting the Bible and we are foolish to pretend that there is. Jesus said, “Watch out for false prophets…By their fruit you will recognize them.”  (Matthew 7:15, 16) The Apostle Paul taught us “the fruit of the Spirit is love, joy, peace, forbearance, kindness, goodness, faithfulness,  gentleness and self-control. “(Galatians 5:22-23) Thus the ultimate Heretic Detection system is the fruit.

I have read criticisms of Bell that were based on his treatment of historical facts, his lack of support for his conclusions, and his biblical interpretation but I have yet to read any critique of him that focuses on his fruit.  From what I can see he appears to be producing Christ followers who appear to love the Lord and who appear to want to love their neighbors.  From what I can see he is doing this to a greater degree than his critics.

So, there you have it – the Jesus method of detecting heretics.  Can we now proceed with our quest to restore Christian Unity or at least civility?


Filed under Theology

7 responses to “I Found It – The Ultimate Heretic Detector System!

  1. I was literally just thinking this. Kudos for not getting sucked in to the dogfight. May you bear much fruit!

  2. Nice Wendy. Just in the past two weeks I have started to ask the question as much as possible, “And what about their fruit?”. We were debating the Calvinist tradition and I asked what the fruit of that is like. I didn’t get a very good answer……

    Rob does produce good fruit.

    • wmccaig

      Dave – Thanks for your comment. I think we get so lost in proving our point we forget what the ultimate outcome is. Jesus clearly cared more about our love of one another than our doctrinal beliefs. Hope you can help your Calvinist friends finds with finding a good answer to your question.

  3. Paula Snell

    I was just thinking about hospital chaplaincy and spirituality and you answered my question. It is about fruit. Am I exhibiting the fruit of the Spirit when I am with a patient or staff person? And am I able to leave them with fruit, i.e. do I leave them with peace, comfort and/or joy etc. Thank you for making theology so practical!

    • wmccaig

      Chaplaincy is a very high calling and often requires that we meet people where they are not where we want them to be. I think it is the fruit that people are attracted to and that allows us to build relationships that then can move into spiritual conversations. If you have no fruit…you will never develop the trust needed for real spiritual conversations. God’s blessing upon your ministry.

  4. Great! I hope you got some refreshing time. I think one mistake that is sometimes made is defining “fruit” as followers. People joining your group is not the same thing as producing the fruit of the spirit, and I love how you emphasized the fruit of the spirit.
    BTW, I didn’t mention this in the other post, but I thought your comparison between striving for Christian unity and racial unity was a really helpful way of looking at it. Thanks.

    • wmccaig

      I did not even touch on the “fruit” as “followers” idea but you are so right in pointing out that “popularity” is not the same thing as “fruitfulness.” I think that the idea that numbers equals success has really damaged the quality of discipleship in this country. That is an entirely different blog post that I will save for another day. I actually touched on it in a post titled “They are not lazy and they don’t want to be entertained” last month. Thanks again for your wonderful comments!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s